Lauren Lapkus

Mal

Nick Rutherford

Cal

Lucy Hale

Jesse

Beck Bennett

Tyson

Dree Hemingway

April

Maya Kazan

Katie

Darrell Britt-Gibson

Charlie

John Kapelos

Louis

Beverly D'Angelo

Edie

Kyle Mooney

Gabe

Jeff Barry

Henry

Elizabeth Ruscio

Aunt Becky

Jeff Grace

Bartender

Ryan Malena Davis

Waiter

Brittany Furlan

Samantha